The Promoter team recently got together for a team outing — we went and saw the movie “Snowden”. If you haven’t seen it, I’d highly recommend you do.
Following the movie, we all had our opinions. Some of us looked at the story that was told, others looked at how the story was told.
It was a brief reminder that no matter what you do as a company, you can’t please everyone.No matter what you do as a company, you can’t please everyone. Optimize on those you can. Click To Tweet
Honestly, the best you can do, is optimize for one of the groups that you can please the most.
As nice as it might be, some of your passives and detractors will just simply never come around to giving you anything higher than an 8 on an NPS survey. The honest truth is that, as a company, you should be ok with that.
As I write this, I’m sitting on a plane, flying back to my home state of Minnesota. And, if you’ve read some of my previous posts, you could probably guess which airline I’m on — Southwest.
I’ve openly confessed my unbridled love for this company and brand. I’m a promoter of Southwest Airlines in every sense of the word.
But guess what? Not everyone is.
Some people don’t care for their cattle call seating. Other people are turned off by their lack of First Class. And others don’t appreciate the personality, and laissez-faire attitude (personally, I love it).
Recently the CEO of Delta Airlines stated that he couldn’t understand how any air traveler would appreciate the Southwest Airlines approach, let alone how anyone could actually fly with them.
Because everyone has unique tastes and opinions, Southwest Airlines doesn’t have a perfect NPS score of 100 (actually there isn’t a company in existence that I’m aware of that does).
Don’t get me wrong, Southwest is no slouch when it comes to their Net Promoter Score. It’s in the 60’s, which is still excellent by NPS standards (and the highest among all airlines).
Of course they would love a score of 100, but they understand, just like any other business on the planet, that an NPS score of 100 isn’t a realistic goal or expectation.
Doing so would mean that they would need to appeal to all customers … making changes in the the very same approach that has brought them to be considered one of the top companies in customer satisfaction, loyalty and retention.
Simply put, going after a perfect NPS score would actually give them the opposite result.
Does that mean that Southwest, or any other company for that matter, should ignore their detractors?
But, it does mean that it’s largely unrealistic to expect that 100% of your detractors can be converted into passives or promoters.
Detractors come in many different varieties. Some are very pliable and only a few degrees away from becoming a happy customer. Others, for whatever the reason, will never come around no matter what you do.
Your job is to identify and optimize on the former.
So you might be left wondering … if the goal isn’t to get to 100, then what is the goal?
In other words, what is a good Net Promoter Score? Or, the question we hear most often, “Do we have have a good score?”.
And, if you’re asking this question, don’t worry, you’re not alone. This is one of the most often asked questions by those that employ the methodology.
The most honest and straightforward answer is that, by itself, the score is largely meaningless. However, I do recognize that people enjoy using it to measure their overall progress and to compare their performance in a competitive landscape.
With that in mind …
What’s a good Net Promoter Score
Based on the global NPS standards, any score above 0 would be considered “good” (50 and above being excellent while 70 and above is considered “world class”).
Simply put, any positive score means that you have more promoters (advocates willing to recommend you) than detractors (unhappy customers and potential negative word-of-mouth).
The more word-of-mouth and advocate mindshare that you control in your industry at any given time will have a very direct impact on your bottom-line growth and overall retention.
With that in mind, you could use your competitor’s score as a benchmark. More specifically though, you need to take your industry into consideration as well.
The cable or telecom industry is a perfect example where the average score is at or below zero.
Another example would be a project we’re working on currently called Net Presidential Score, using NPS to measure the sentiment of the voters as it relates to each US presidential candidate. Both Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump have NPS scores well below zero. In the world of politics, a “good” NPS score, as unfortunate as it may be, is still negative.
The bottom line is, your overall score is a result of your efforts, not the goal itself.
Even if the bar is set lower within your respective industry, your focus should be on listening to the needs of your customers and making continual improvements to serve those needs in order grow the overall sentiment towards your brand. A “good” score will follow.